Hardcore Legends Sheer Terror Take the Proud Boys Down a Notch

by | Sep 26, 2018 | MUSIC

NYCHC legends Sheer Terror have just taken the Proud Boys founder, Gavin McInnes, down a proverbial notch. In a Facebook post from Monday, Sheer Terror singer Paul Bearer wrote on the band’s page:

“It’s been brought to our attention that Gavin McInnes was speaking favorably about us on his podcast… Just to make things as clear as possible so there is no mistaking where we stand: ‘PROUD BOYS’ ARE NOT WELCOME HERE, OR ANYWHERE WE MIGHT BE.’” 

McInnes, a former founder of VICE, has been an influential figure in the alt-right community. His brand of western identity politics and chauvinism has been on the forefront of a contemporary white nationalist movement that uses coded language to mask an agenda, which according to the Southern Poverty Law Center, “maintain[s] affiliations with known extremists.” This includes known anti-Muslim and anti-immigration groups. 

McInnes was quoted in June of this year saying, “It’s such a rape culture with these immigrants, I don’t even think these women see it as rape. They see it as just like having a teeth [sic] pulled. ‘It’s a Monday. I don’t really enjoy it,’ but that’s what you do. I wouldn’t be surprised if it doesn’t have the same trauma as it would for a middle-class white girl in the suburbs because it’s so entrenched into their culture.” 

His group, known simply as the Proud Boys, proclaim that they are “proud Western chauvinists” and were present in support of the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville in August 2017. The organizer of Unite the Right, Jason Kessler, was seen in a Periscope video being jumped into a Proud Boys group in June of the same year. The are identifiable by their black and yellow Fred Perry shirts and have chapters in the UK, Australia, and Canada. 

Sheer Terror, a staple of New York City Hardcore in the 80s and 90s, has maintained a consistent following since then with its brand of tough guy hardcore, also known for its humor, irony, and a pervasive sarcasm. The band’s Ugly and Proud remains one of the staples of hardcore music 21 years after its release.

RVA Mag caught up with singer Paul Bearer about the band’s post and how white nationalist groups have been touting their love for punk and hardcore bands.

“They must not be listening to the lyrics to some of these bands. I can’t speak for all of them,” Bearer said. “The whole ‘Conservatism Is The New Punk’ thought is a fucking travesty, and a sad joke. I don’t want to hear about how you’ve ‘grown up, and have kids and a mortgage.’ You don’t eat shit just because the toilet’s closer than the fridge.”

And it is precisely Bearer’s humor and sarcasm that was on display in the heated Facebook exchange, which has now been shared 278 times with over 385 comments. More so, since self-identified members of the Proud Boys have been quick to defend their eponymous leader on the thread. One commenter attempted to call out Bearer for “virtue signaling,” while simultaneously referring to the Proud Boys as a “multi-racial men’s club.” Another commenter said, “Sheer Terror, I suppose you support Socialism and the destruction of American principles and family values too? That’s pretty American these days.”

As the back and forth picked up momentum, Bearer finally said what everyone knows, “…they imply racism. Without actually calling it ‘racism’.”

He then went on to tell the Proud Boy defenders, “Fuck you where you breathe [sic] with your smarmy comebacks. You want nothing to do with me? Then, walk son.” 

The response was a classic retort, which echoes one of their classic songs, “I Spoiler (Bulldog Edition),” where mid-song, he tells someone to fuck off by saying,”Why don’t you hightail your ass back to Toronto, you lousy Canadian scumbag.” 

Not long after he changed tactics, he offered to put Proud Boys and their defenders on the guest list to their next show. “I take it all back. Proud Boys are VERY welcome to come see us play,” Bearer said. “Let’s see how that works out for you,OK? Is that fair? Come run your mouths. Please. I’ll even put you on the guest list. OK? Is that cool? I personally invite you to any show that we’re playing. Don’t disappoint me, now…” 

While Bearer makes it clear that he is not necessarily down with “AntiFA,” he supports anti-fascism overall, saying, “I stand with and for the working men & women, the downtrodden, the voiceless, the underdog, the AMERICAN PEOPLE, no matter what color, creed, or religion,” proving once and for all, old hardcore dudes can still kick it with the best of them.


Music Sponsored By Graduate Richmond

Landon Shroder

Landon Shroder

Landon is a foreign policy and communications professional from Richmond specializing in high risk and complex environments, spending almost fifteen years abroad in the Middle East and Africa. He hold’s a Master’s Degree from American University in Conflict Resolution and was a former journalist and producer for VICE Media. His writing on foreign affairs has been published in World Policy Journal, Chatham House, Small Wars Journal, War on the Rocks, and the Fair Observer, along with being a commentator in the New York Times on the Middle East.

more in music

An Ode to Oderus Urungus, Our Scum Dog Overlord!

Once upon a time, in Richmond, Virginia, there stood a statue of Robert E. Lee on Monument Avenue for 133 years. However, in the wake of the summer of 2020 protests and growing social awareness, the State Supreme Court approved the removal of the statue. Governor...

The Butcher Brown & The Richmond Symphony Put On A Show

Butcher Brown, the progressive jazz masters from Richmond, played a special show in partnership with the Richmond Symphony over the Martin Luther King Jr. weekend. The show featured 10 of their tunes arranged by Richmond’s own Trey Pollard and Tim Barrons which they...

A Man Named Earl, A Punk Named Yonder

Richmond based punk artist Yonder opens up about his art and music career, and the role that mental health plays in it. He discusses how his "outsider" attitude and vulnerability in his work is rooted in his experiences growing up as the "black sheep" of his family...

RVA Shows You Must See This Week: January 11 – January 17

FEATURED SHOW Saturday, January 14, 7 PM Last Minute Fest II, feat. The Mitras, Mad Abbey, Pipesleeve, Overunderdog, Sifter, Stevie Ashe @ The Camel - $10 in advance, $12 day of show (Order tickets HERE) It's officially a new year, but I always take a little while to...

Richmond Music 2022, Part II: Indie (Second Half)

OK, I should have known that this one in particular would go too long -- when I made up these playlists before starting to write this article series, the indie playlist was the longest one by a significant amount. To put it in perspective, the rather lengthy hip hop...

Pin It on Pinterest