Decades of mismanagement have led to a heating crisis for Richmonders during this brutally cold winter. Residents affected by malfunctioning heating systems pay on a sliding scale, many near market rate, to the Richmond Redevelopment Housing Authority for concrete block housing marred by neglect and disrepair.
“Welcome to poverty,” Sha Randa Taylor said when she opened her door in Creighton Court. Taylor isn’t used to living like this. The 31-year-old was born in Highland Park in Northside Richmond and works as a nurse, which makes her monthly rent $800 for a unit she can’t live in due to heat and health issues. She’s lived in public housing for the first time over this last year after a high-risk pregnancy and subchorionic hematomas temporarily took her out of work.
“Touch the walls, they’re cold,” she said during our visit this past Monday. Even through my gloves and two coats, I could feel the cold seeping through. Her house was the last on a tour of four Richmond housing courts we took, led by local activists Omari Kadaffi and Chelsea Higgs Wise. The two have been highlighting unbearable living conditions citywide and working with residents to improve conditions.
It’s not just the heat. We saw evidence of rodent infestation at Taylor’s home despite her clean floors, carefully packaged food, and minimal furniture, and she said her doctor told her the rodent droppings are making her sick.
Like many of the people we visited, she didn’t have enough heaters and has been staying with family. She’s deeply unhappy about the way RRHA has treated her. “They laughed at me,” she said about an earlier visit to the rental office, during which the workers called the police on her to make her leave, but then finally agreed to give her two space heaters, which were delivered during RVA Magazine’s visit.
In Kadaffi’s words, it’s “planned blight,” a view he supports by running through the history of public housing in America. Lowest bidder construction and placement on the other side of highway systems that cut across cities set the stage for isolated, low-quality, walled-in living conditions. Recent mismanagement at RRHA saw the authority slapped with a $6.5 million bill for ineligible or inappropriate spending, and news reports have covered years of financial impropriety at the office.
Although the issue is bigger than just heat, the crisis is the immediate concern. “I asked the RRHA leadership why this was never treated as an emergency case,” Councilman Parker Agelasto said. “Let’s get it fixed, treat it as an emergency, and get it repaired.”
“They’ve come and asked for funding for construction, but not for heating. Since the last week of October, 72 percent of the days have been cold enough to open the cold weather overflow shelter–if the city can do that on an emergency basis, why has RRHA not treated heating for its residents on an emergency basis?”
The Richmond NAACP had the same question, which they’ve discussed on conference calls, at a rally Monday night, and in a general meeting on Tuesday.
“We’re demanding a full accounting and timeline of the situation,” said James “J.J.” Minor, local NAACP president, sharing plans for an official letter and a town hall meeting they’ll organize over the next 10 days. The group anticipates bringing together some 400 residents and activists to put pressure on RRHA to ensure that this never happens again. They will request a detailed analysis of infrastructure problems and a proposal to fix them in a timely fashion.
For their part, RRHA said in a city council meeting on Monday that senior management didn’t know about the issue until October 2017, but admitted that lower-level staff members knew about the problem sooner. NAACP meeting attendees were skeptical and unhappy with the response to date, which has largely consisted of 2-3 space heaters per unit and offers of hotel rooms to only a small number of those affected.
Minor invited Lt. William Andrews of the Richmond Fire Department to speak to the safety and proper use of space heaters. “Electric space heaters should be for short-term usage or just supplementary,” he said, confirming the fears of attendees. “These heaters aren’t for overnight use.” He also highlighted the high energy usage of the heaters. A single heater takes up most of the power on a single circuit, a big problem when a small home with only a few circuits needs three to maintain heat.
If that’s the solution RRHA proposes, it seems to have left many in the cold. It’s been reported that seven of 49 families offered the opportunity to relocate have accepted, and some residents in Creighton Court were offered free hotel stays by Shamin Hotels, but of the residents we spoke with, none were offered hotels or enough heaters to warm their house. Although Creighton has been the focus for many local media outlets, RVA Mag investigated units in Gilpin, Fairfield, and Whitcomb courts that also didn’t have adequate heat.
Michelle Jennings, an author and behavioral specialist living in Gilpin Court, said maintenance lectured her for using her oven for heat when they finally got to her house. “He says, ‘you’re not supposed to do that.’ ‘Well, I got little ones here, and it’s cold,” she said. She had space heaters, but they were taken away just before the cold snap.
Jennings is one of many residents on an interactive map Kadaffi maintains, listing 39 units in addition to the known problems at the 54 units in Creighton. As we visited the people on this map, we found the same problem city-wide.
Madison Scott was one of those residents, living in Fairfield Court, with his three children. He’s had to send them to relatives on the coldest days, splitting up his family over space concerns, while he sleeps in the unheated unit. “They tell me they just don’t have the money to fix the heat,” he said showing us the gas oven he uses for heat. The radiators are cold to the touch.
In Whitcomb Court, Latoi Lyle said neither her oven nor her heat have worked since she moved in a year and a half ago. The oven leaked gas, a problem that took RRHA two weeks to look at after the Fire Department shut it off for safety, but one they still haven’t fixed. They’ve come out several times for the heat.
“The heat comes on after they come, but it shuts off after 30 minutes,” she said, noting that she’s stopped calling them because while the workers are nice, they never fix anything, and she has to pay fees for their visits.
RVA Mag tried to reach RRHA for comment for over two days, with many calls transferred to full voicemail systems that could not accept messages. The scope of the problem is currently unknown but seems widespread, and Kadaffi points to an official statement from RRHA CEO T.K. Somanath detailing problems in some 3,000 units that need to be addressed.
Many activists are unhappy with Somanath, including Maurice Tyler, founder of Coaches Against Violence Everywhere, and one of the organizers of the Monday night rally that drew nearly 100 concerned citizens out on a wet, cold night to the doorstep of the RRHA offices.
“He got to go,” Tyler told me at the NAACP meeting, referring to Somanath. “It’s not about him personally, it’s about doing the job. How many games do you have to lose before you realize it’s your coach that’s failing?” Like many at the NAACP meeting, Tyler wanted to see a proactive approach with an increase in oversight of the RRHA.
A proactive approach is exactly what political leaders are calling for too, from Congressman Donald McEachin’s statements to our conversation with Agelasto today.
“You can’t simply focus on future construction,” Agelasto said. “And that’s a concern we have across the board, with schools and city buildings too. We need to build but we also need to maintain our buildings. These are partnerships and there needs to be accountability.”
If RRHA can stick to its current timeline, residents can expect to have heat again by Feb. 12, but long-term issues remain. “Nobody that I’ve talked to has ever had fully operational heat,” Kadaffi said, in a final call before press time. “Doesn’t matter if they’ve lived there 11 years or 25 years, they’ve always had to use their ovens to heat their houses when it gets cold.”
“I do have confidence that they’ll do the best they can right now because it’s become a very big issue,” he said. Like everyone else we spoke to, he thinks more has to change, too.
“We will not accept any plan going forward that doesn’t include a full leadership change,” he said. “T.K. [Somanath] tried to blame the maintenance people yesterday, but there’s no way that other people didn’t know. Maybe he didn’t know, but others did. We need to clear out the corruption.”
*Photos by Landon Shroder