Precious: A Complicated Triumph

by | Dec 3, 2009 | POLITICS

Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire directed by Lee Daniels has garnered a lot of controversy and commentary since the November release.

Precious: Based on the Novel ‘Push’ by Sapphire directed by Lee Daniels has garnered a lot of controversy and commentary since the November release. The big screen adaptation of the award-winning novel Push: A Novel by Sapphire from 1996 boasts a unique supporting cast of entertainment heavy weights in roles that reach far outside of their usual characters. New comer, Gabourey Sidibe, makes her acting debut as the title character- an illiterate, pregnant teenager living in Harlem with intensely abusive parents. The film cast Mariah Carey, Mo’Nique, Paula Patton and Lenny Kravitz in supporting roles. There has already been Oscar buzz for supporting roles and the film has won several awards at Sundance and the Toronto Film Festivals and has been nominated for a slew of others including several top awards at the Independent Spirit Awards. -LV

A Complicated Triumph by Dr. Bertram Ashe

Precious has a problem.

It’s an extremely powerful film. It has that quality that all terrific narratives have: it pulls you in, grabs you by the ears, aims your attention, thoughts, and emotion at the screen and refuses to let them go until end credits roll.

There’s just no denying that Precious is an excellent film. The problem with Precious is that pesky double-consciousness. It’s not one film, it’s two films in one. Over a hundred years ago, W.E.B. DuBois, in The Souls of Black Folk, wrote about black America’s double-consciousness, this sense, as he put it, “of always looking at one’s self through the eyes of others, of measuring one’s soul by the tape of a world that looks on in amused contempt and pity.” That was the issue that confronted Sapphire when she originally wrote Push, the novel on which the film was based, and it’s the issue for the film itself. The problem isn’t with the film; the problem is its simultaneous status as cultural document, as inevitable statement on black America.

Me, I try my best to ignore double-consciousness. I know it’s real, I know it lurks, but I want to feel as if I can live my life unfettered by racial weight, unencumbered by the sense that I always have to be aware of “whut de white folks think.” Who cares what they think, I tell myself. What does it really matter?

And for the most part, I’ve trained myself to convince myself that it doesn’t matter at all. Yes, dammit, Precious was, after all, a good film. But then I think about the fact that the literary agent representing Sapphire sold Push for six figures in a matter of hours, even though it was only a partial, one hundred-page manuscript. I think to myself: three-hundred pound, ghetto-bound, illiterate 13-year-old black girl, pregnant with her second child, both by her father. And against my will, my double-consciousness beeper goes off, loud and long. That’s how they see us, I can’t help thinking. That’s why publishers are so eager to buy, because they know it’ll sell. That’s who they think we are. Animals who’ll eat anything, screw anything and anybody.

I wish I didn’t have to think that way; I try not to think that way. I have white colleagues I appreciate, white friends I enjoy—but I’m just not as blithely innocent as the next guy. I can’t fool myself into playing the we’re-all-colorblind/race-doesn’t-matter game. It does matter. And yet… The wonderful, amazing thing about Lee Daniels’ film is that he somehow found a way, wading through all the dysfunction, all the presumed pathology, all the poverty, the abuse, the rape-pregnancy-AIDS pain, to find and underscore Precious’s humanity.

And that’s the bottom line for me. Is it a shame that the only way America can pay attention to the black urban poor is via a fictional 300-pound incest victim? Yes. But while white America might enter the theater ready to marvel, yet again, at bestial black people, the triumph of Precious is that they must leave the theater understanding that the title character, though pluck and grit and tenacity, finds and affirms her essential humanity. None of that solves the problem of double-consciousness, but I guess, for now, that will just have to do.

Dr. Bertram Ashe, Associate Professor if English at the University if Richmond weighs in on this important film and the existence of double-consciousness in this film and in life.

Ashe is the author of several books and essays including From within the Frame: Storytelling in African-American Fiction. (New York: Routledge, 2002.) “‘Under the Umbrella of Black Civilization’: A Conversation with Reginal McKnight,” African American Review, Vol. 35, No. 3, 427-437 (Autumn 2001) and “‘Why Don’t He like My Hair?’: Constructing African-American Standards of Beauty in Toni Morrison’s ‘Song of Solomon’ and Zora Neale Hurston’s ‘Their Eyes Were Watching God,'” African American Review, v.29 (1995)

RVA Staff

RVA Staff

Since 2005, the dedicated team at RVA Magazine, known as RVA Staff, has been delivering the cultural news that matters in Richmond, VA. This talented group of professionals is committed to keeping you informed about the events and happenings in the city.

more in politics

There Will Be No Casino: The Lessons of November 7th, 2023

It’s over. Again. Richmond beat back the ghouls of predatory greed and political prostitution. After a battle, all seems eerily quiet. The quiet unsettles if not followed by the housekeeping of the battlefield - damage reports need filing, and new plans need...

Who Are We Becoming?

Voting No Casino & Reclaiming a Radical Vision of Solidarity & Economic Freedom Amidst a Divisive Casino Campaign Over the weekend, I learned that one of the owners of the proposed casino who is also one of the most powerful Black women in America, Cathy...

What Virginia College Students Need to know About Voting

This story is for subscribers to VCU’s Capital News Service. If you have questions or comments, please contact Alix Bryan at or 804-921-0114. RICHMOND, Va. – College-aged people are among the largest voting block, yet tend to have the lowest turnout in...

Labor Peace or Lawsuits?

This piece is one in a series of opinion pieces by Jon Baliles about the proposed Richmond Grand Resort and Casino. You can read his other pieces HERE. The casino advocates made a big deal about their labor peace agreement that was reached with the Washington,...

Make It Impossible to Happen Again

This piece is one in a series of opinion pieces by Jon Baliles about the proposed Richmond Grand Resort and Casino. You can read his other pieces HERE. The Richmond Times-Dispatch Editorial Board and reporters sat down this week with the casino opponents who said the...

Resorts Like Airports

There has been a lot of boasting from the casino advocates about their partnership with Kentucky-based Churchill Downs, Inc. (CDI). The rebranded Richmond Grand casino developer Urban One is a radio and TV conglomerate that has said they are partnering with CDI...


Pin It on Pinterest