After Judicial Review, Recount Results in 94th District in Newport News Becomes A Tie

by | Dec 20, 2017 | COMMUNITY

*This is a developing story. 

A single vote brought victory to Shelly Simonds in the House of Delegate race yesterday, but after the three-panel judge reviewed the recount, it looks like a single vote has taken that victory away.

At issue was a single ballot marked for every Republican, and for Simonds and incumbent David Yancey. Officials yesterday agreed that it should be thrown out, but one official, Kenneth Mallory, changed his mind and wrote a letter asking that the ballot be recounted. Attorneys for Yancey submitted the letter over objections from attorneys for Simonds.

After hours of examination, the judicial panel announced that they would count the ballot, bringing the final total to 11,608 for each candidate, ending the race in a tie. Virginia law mandates that ties be determined “by lot”, meaning that the decision will come down to luck.

The vote will likely be determined by choosing between two film canisters at random from a glass bowl; each canister will have the name of a single candidate in it. The game of chance can also be contested, which would result in a second recount.

Social media users have responded in disbelief after seeing the ballot, posted by Jordan Pascale of the Virginian Pilot, which has lines or cross marks through bubbles next to both Ed Gillespie and Simonds.

The ballot in question

If Yancey wins, the GOP will continue to hold the majority in the House of Delegates. If he loses, the House will need to find a way to work across party lines. Unlike elections, there is no tie breaker for the House of Delegates; a tied vote means nothing changes.

David Streever

David Streever

David Streever was editor of the RVA Mag print quarterly from 2017 until 2018. He's written two cycling books for Falcon and covered the Tour de France and the 2015 UCI Championship in Richmond. He writes about politics, culture, cycling, and pretty much anything else.




more in community

From The Village Cafe to Literary Fame: Tom Robbins Dies at 92

Tom Robbins, the celebrated author known for his whimsical storytelling and philosophical wit, passed away on February 9, 2025, at the age of 92 in La Conner, Washington. Though he became a literary icon in the Pacific Northwest, Robbins' formative years in Richmond,...

It’s Still Our City Podcast | Ep. 3 Russian Vampp

“Richmond’s own Raunchy Chandelier, Emma (aka Empress de Naste’), is a local artist, burlesque performer, and the producer behind Immodest Opulence Productions. Before stepping into the burlesque scene, this VCU fashion grad found her footing working at Carytown...

You Know It’s Bad When Waffle House Is Raising Egg Prices

Waffle House is the kind of place that doesn’t flinch. Hurricanes, power outages, late-night chaos—it stays open through it all. The idea of it closing or changing is almost unthinkable. But now, something’s shifted. They’re not closing their doors, but they’re...

Photos | Trump Protests in Richmond and DC

Hundreds of people gathered at Richmond’s Capitol Square on Wednesday as part of the nationwide 50501 Movement, protesting President Trump’s Project 2025 agenda. Organized by Dia Figueroa, the rally focused on opposing proposed cuts to reproductive rights, stricter...

Richmond’s SCAG Gallery Pushes for Equity in the Art Market

In the barrenness of the winter months, SCAG (Southside Contemporary Art Gallery) provides a vivid contrast. Hull Street is alive with people hustling about the red brick buildings and snow-encrusted sidewalks. The gallery itself resembles a greenhouse, its entrance...