Stop Using History as an Excuse to Not Build a New Stadium (Use these Studies Instead)

by | Oct 20, 2021 | COMMUNITY

The city, or maybe just Mayor Jones, has doubled down on what some consider to be his name-sake project – a new baseball stadium in Shockoe Bottom.


The city, or maybe just Mayor Jones, has doubled down on what some consider to be his name-sake project – a new baseball stadium in Shockoe Bottom.

A complex marketing project, Loving RVA, was the first step in the sales pitch for Richmonders to buy into this stadium idea, and many does it sound sweet. But the more I read peoples complaints about the stadium, I see the same arguments being rehashed over and over again – don’t pave over history.

First off, the first piece of cement placed in Shockoe bottom paved over history. Then the I-95 expansion that ripped Jackson Ward in half cut history’s throat. And the recent study that show RVA as one of the most economically divided cities in the state gave history a vasectomy to make sure it couldn’t have kids to talk about how poorly it was treated.

None of this was right, and none of this is an excuse for the awful things that have happened, or continue to happen, here in Richmond.

But to continue to say economic development has to be stopped because it will erase history is a weak argument – one that the city itself is all to ready to fight. Enter the proposed slave museum alone side the baseball stadium.

Now I’m a white man, and I realize I don’t have the personal identity to connect with the brutal, unforgiving, and generally awful history that occurred in the Bottom during the height of the slave trade. Between 1830 and 1860, Richmond was the largest slave market in the US. Shockoe has been compared to the Statue of Liberty for slavery – white Europeans can trace their families to Ellis Island, and black Americans can trace their roots to Richmond’s slave trade. There is an undeniable amount of history in those streets.

And Mayor Jones has a museum in the works to make sure that history is remembered. Now some might say a museum, or “heritage site,” might not be enough. But I’m inclined to er on the side of reason here and say the current setup – a trail market by signs and a grassed over field (which will both still exist after construction) could only be made better by a multi-million dollar building that will aim to create a modern, high quality, and historically accurate presentation of how incredibly effed up Richmond’s role in slavery really was.

There, history solved. Stop saying “No stadium on the backs of our ancestors” because they are literally building a museum to commemorate them.

Now, lets look at why it’s actually a bad idea to build a stadium in Shockoe Bottom – the money.

The city wants to spend

Brad Kutner

Brad Kutner

Brad Kutner is the former editor of GayRVA and RVAMag from 2013 - 2017. He’s now the Richmond Bureau Chief for Radio IQ, a state-wide NPR outlet based in Roanoke. You can reach him at BradKutnerNPR@gmail.com




more in community

Photos | Warriors in Bloom at Agecroft Hall

For one weekend, Agecroft Hall stopped being a museum and became a kingdom.  What began as a fundraiser to help launch Richmond's first Renaissance Faire has grown into a destination of its own. Warriors in Bloom, created by the folks at Virago Alley, returned with...

Dispatch from the Lewis Ginter Picket Line

An on-the-ground account of the strike that prompted Jesse Welles and Graham Nash to cancel their Richmond performances. Tensions escalated as Jesse Welles called off his performance at Lewis Ginter Botanical Garden yesterday amid an ongoing union fight for higher...

Far-Right “Remigration” Propaganda Targets Bhatti Campaign

Several campaign signs for Democratic congressional candidate Salaam Bhatti were vandalized over the weekend with professionally printed flyers telling him to "return to your homeland" in multiple languages. The flyers also featured the hashtag #Remigration, a term...

In Plan 9 We Trust

This weekend, Plan 9 Music marks 45 years in Richmond with a party at Hardywood Park Craft Brewery. Over the past four and a half decades, the Richmond institution weathered some of the most turbulent periods in music history. It closed stores, sold its warehouse and...

RVA Pro Wrestling is on a Tear Right Now

Last year, Dogwood Dell was packed out. The hillside was full, the crowd was loud and RVA Pro Wrestling put on one hell of a show. It wasn't just wrestling. It was entertainment built for a Richmond audience, mixing big personalities, over-the-top antics and...

Richmond is a Big World Cup Town

Richmond may not be hosting a World Cup match, but plenty of people here are watching. According to television ratings reported by Sports Business Journal, Richmond-Petersburg ranked among Fox Sports’ top 10 local markets during the opening portion of the tournament....

Good Day RVA is Back and Bringing Friends Along

For four nights this weekend, bands from different generations of Richmond's music scene are taking over Get Tight Lounge. Called Tonal Recall, the series is part reunion show, part showcase and part excuse for a bunch of old friends to get back in the same room. ...

Topics: