All Hail Katie Crutchfield, Goddess of My Icy, Guarded Heart

by | Jan 28, 2014 | MUSIC

Waxahatchee played Strange Matter Saturday night with a stacked lineup full of awesome lady musicians who feel a lot of feelings. And it kicked ass.


Waxahatchee played Strange Matter Saturday night with a stacked lineup full of awesome lady musicians who feel a lot of feelings. And it kicked ass.

I arrived in time to see Cayetana, an all-lady, melodic, sad-ish indie band from Philly. The frontwoman crooned beautifully while the rhythm section kept the songs upbeat. Next up were All Dogs from Columbus. Boasting a front lady with one of the most angelic voices I’ve heard in a while, All Dogs delivered similarly sad rock. All Dogs gets emo with it–spouting lyrics like, “I want you, and you want me, but I’ll fuck it up, just wait and see”–but the rhythm section keeps it upbeat.


Photo by Samantha Marble

Then along came Katie Crutchfield, aka Waxahatchee, aka one of the best live acts I’ve seen in years. I’ve been following Crutchfield since she was in P.S. Eliot, which consisted of her and her sister Allison (now of Swearin’). Last time I saw Waxahatchee, she was strumming solo on her acoustic guitar in a teeny tiny venue in Harrisonburg. This time around, Waxahatchee toured as a full band, complete with drums, a bass, and two guitars.

Cerulean Salt, released in March of last year, made basically every music critic’s “best of 2013” list, and for good reason. Crutchfield’s self-assured, focused and clear on the 13 song recording, and she’s so goddamn honest it hurts. “Escape yells both our names out loud/we run like hell, I’ll write a tragic epilogue and you’ll act it out,” she sings in “Dixie Cups and Jars.” I mean, come on, she’s brilliant.

Crutchfield remained the star of the show, and believe you me, she knows how to be a front woman. She crooned (there was a lot of crooning on Saturday) her perfectly written sad songs about fucked up love and depression while standing proudly at the edge of the stage. Something I love about Waxahatchee – something that separates Crutchfield from her fellow musicians – is that she knows exactly who she is, what her problems are, and is not afraid to proclaim them in front of the world. And she does it just beautifully.

After playing a full set (which was shorter than everyone wanted, but, hey, most of her songs clock in at around two minutes), she gave us an encore. “I can only play more songs if I sing them solo,” she said, knowingly. But before playing two crowd favorites – “Bathtub” and “Swan Dive” – she shut down an annoying heckler who wouldn’t stop screaming for her to play Madonna’s “Material Girl.” “If this guy has any friends, I will give you a free t-shirt if you just get him the fuck out of here,” she announced, standing her ground like the badass she is.

Katie Crutchfield manages to say everything I’m thinking, and just don’t have the balls – or poetic writing skills – to say. Check out Cerulean Salt HERE. Preferably while you’re sitting alone, naked in your bedroom at 3 am after being scorned by your lover.

Marilyn Drew Necci

Marilyn Drew Necci

Former GayRVA editor-in-chief, RVA Magazine editor for print and web. Anxiety expert, proud trans woman, happily married.




more in music

Iron Blossom is Part of a Bigger Richmond Music Story

Ahead of Iron Blossom, we talked with veteran promoter Ken Macdonald about the city’s changing live music ecosystem, from clubs to festivals and the Allianz Amphitheater. Richmond has always been a music town, but going back decades there were gaps in the local scene....

A First Look at the New Brown’s Island

Brown's Island has been closed since November 2025 for a $30 million improvement project, the largest renovation of the six-acre island in decades. It will temporarily reopen for the Richmond Folk Festival, October 9 - 11th, giving Richmonders their first chance to...

Richmond Loves Dolly Parton

I was gonna kill my husband in a cab in Peru, but “Islands in the Stream” came on the radio, and we stopped arguing and started singing. She could do that to you. You could totally be feeling some type of way, but if you put some Dolly Parton on, well, then you got a...

Night Idea Has Been Here the Whole Time.

Richmond has no shortage of bands that arrive and then disappear. Night Idea has taken the opposite approach. They’ve been around for 16 years, and keep getting better. I sat down with Joey Anderson, Reggie Pace and Reyna Pannell ahead of Night Idea’s appearance at...

You Can Kiss Off! 45 Years of Violent Femmes

You can always kiss off into the air. Behind my back, I can see them stare. They hurt me bad, and I don’t mind. They hurt me bad, they do it all the time! Yeah, yeah. You just sang that in your head, didn’t you? I believe it is impossible not to. There’s an alchemy, a...

Read the Virginia Pride 2026 Pride Guide 🏳️‍🌈

For more than a decade, RVA Magazine has worked with Virginia Pride to produce the Official VA PrideFest Guide, bringing together stories from Richmond’s LGBTQ+ community and everything you need to know for PrideFest this Saturday, September 12,...

Virginia Film Chief Andy Edmunds Made a Movie

For context, when I’m not writing for this magazine, I’m a director and producer in the film industry. There’s one person rallying troops in the trenches for me and my colleagues all over the state. Andy Edmunds is on the front line of the conversations that bring...