The Lives Destroyed by the Mountain Valley Pipeline

by | Dec 6, 2017 | PHOTO

It’s a frightening thing to realize that despite spending years in one place, despite working hard over decades to make your house a home, despite being dutifully on time with property taxes and mortgage payments, someone could rip your home away to build a pipeline. RVA Mag traveled to Giles County, Virginia to document the lives and stories of some of the people most affected by the proposed Mountain Valley Pipeline (MVP). 

David and Karen Yolton have spent the last 50 years turning a little pony barn into the loving home of a teacher and a retired land surveyor. Georgia Haverty, a single mother, has spent 40 years converting her 400 acres of farmland into four lucrative businesses with her daughter, including selling beef cattle and creating a wedding venue. Don Jones and his family have worked and tilled the same farmland in Giles County for ten generations.

They are all at risk of losing their homes, trees, land, water, and livelihoods to this pipeline.

David and Karen Yolton

The Mountain Valley Pipeline, LLC sued over 300 landowners throughout Virginia’s Appalachian region three weeks ago. The majority of these landowners are represented by lawyers, and several are plaintiffs in a separate lawsuit filed by Bold Alliance against MVP, Atlantic Coast Pipeline, LLC (ACP), and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC).

Fern and Earl Echols, 77 and 81 respectively, have also lived in their Giles County home for nearly 50 years. Their six grandchildren and six great-grandchildren pile into the house every year to spend the holidays with their maw-maw. Fern has been taking care of her husband for over 30 years, who suffers from pancreatic complications.

Fern and Earl Echols

“One night we went to bed and [Earl] said, ‘If this takes place, it will finish me,’” Fern Echols said. “‘With this pipeline, I’ve been thinking about it. I can sit here and look around in my home and I don’t want to pack up and leave it. It will finish me.’”

The proposed pipeline and proposed pipeline service road will frame their property and come so close to their small home that MVP has asked them to relocate during the construction period.

“We have worked hard in our little bungalow here to be comfortable,” Echols said. “Honey, I’m not ready to move.”

Karolyn Givens, whose late husband’s family farm is in the path of the pipeline, was served a stack of nearly 200 pages along with the other 300 landowners in the area. She came home to two court issued stacks of paper duct taped to her front door for both herself and her deceased husband of one month. These companies not only have resorted to a base attempt at legal attrition, but according to Givens, they are guilty of inappropriately distributing court summons.

Karolyn Givens

The proposed project is a 42-inch-wide natural gas pipeline that will stretch 303 miles from northwestern West Virginia to southern Virginia, crossing through the mountainous Appalachian region that includes the George Washington National Forest and the Blue Ridge Mountain range. The path comes within 50 feet of many of these landowners’ personal homes, which will not only disrupt their property but has the potential to create high-risk areas for rupture, according to many landowners.

“Where they’re going to build the pipeline is going right through those trees and across up on the mountain,” Givens said. “There’s a cave and a sinkhole on the scheduled path. This is karst land. We have our earthquakes.”

Dawn Echols Cisek

Carolyn Elefant, the lawyer for Bold Alliance representing landowners in their fight against MVP, ACP, and FERC predicts that because of the complicated nature of the case, it will likely go to the Supreme Court. In addition to the constitutionality of a private corporation using eminent domain, several other new legal issues are introduced, such as the environmental impact inflicted by this project.

Don Jones and His Father

A case like this moving from the appeals court to the Supreme Court could set an important precedent for other unwanted pipeline projects, such as the Dakota Access Pipeline (DAP). In 2016, protests against DAP at the Standing Rock Indian Reservation stressed the outrage native peoples felt against the pipeline, which threatened their drinking water and ancient burial grounds.

Although the MVP does not disrupt Native American land, this proposed pipeline is projected to deface the Newport Historic District in Giles County, Virginia. Historic properties that have been part of this small corner of Virginia will be plowed through like garbage.

The population in Giles County is just over 16,000. The population of the Standing Rock Reservation is just over 8,000. In Nelson County, where the ACP will run, it’s just under 15,000. These companies have continually targeted populations they believe won’t fight back: Native American reservations, rural Appalachia, Native American harvest grounds, and rural farmlands.

Georgia Haverty

These are small, agrarian counties and communities that feel ignored by their political representatives and don’t appear to have the necessary manpower to fight back. However, nearly all 300 landowners have personal legal representation as well as multiple lawsuits against these companies.

MVP may be getting more than they bargained for. 


*All photos by Jason Lappa  

Madelyne Ashworth

Madelyne Ashworth

Madelyne is a Richmond native and staff writer at RVA Magazine, primarily covering politics and white nationalism in Virginia. She spent the past four years working and living in D.C., earning her B.A. in journalism and running to the White House every time the President sneezed. Follow her on Twitter at @madelyne_ash.

more in photo

The Empowerment Of Otherness With Richmond Film Artist Evie Metz

Richmond filmmaker Evie Metz is an interdisciplinary artist centered in sculpture, photography, and puppet stop-motion animation. Her work, in collaboration with artist Nick Daly, explores the relationship between humans, animals, and nature and the empowerment of...

The Last Richmond Fall 2022 Photo Set Of The Year!

To be totally honest, there are only so many photos of the city skyline or James River we can look at. We get a ton of people sending us this stuff everyday. That's totally cool (and we support this happening) but at some point we gotta call it and let our audience...

Tudor Opulence In RVA: Exploring Virginia House

Where Richmond's old money is concerned, it doesn't get much older or more moneyed than the Windsor Farms neighborhood, which starts on the south side of Cary Street Rd, just west of Carytown, and runs south all the way to the shores of the James. There are quite a...

Pin It on Pinterest