F-You ICE – Chesterfield County becomes first VA county to ignore federal immigrant detainee requests

by | Nov 12, 2014 | POLITICS

Chesterfield County will no longer honor requests to hold illegal immigrants at the request of the federal ICE unit.


Chesterfield County will no longer honor requests to hold illegal immigrants at the request of the federal ICE unit.

The Chesterfield Observer reported that the county’s sheriff’s office made the call after recent federal court cases have suggested localities could get sued for holding detainees past legal limits.

The higher courts said the “immigration detainer” from ICE, the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency which handles boarder patrol, deportations, detaining illegal immigrants, etc., were just administrative requests, and not mandatory.

ICE immigration detainers were used to keep those arrested in custody 48 hours beyond the legal limit so the federal agency could run background checks, confirm a person’s immigration status, and transfer the arrested person into federal custody if they turn out to be here illegally.

Details via Chesterfield Observer:

According to an opinion issued earlier this year by the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals in Pennsylvania in reference to a lawsuit in Pennsylvania, “immigration detainers do not and cannot compel a state or local law enforcement agency to detain suspected aliens subject to removal.”

By enforcing the detainer, the court said, the local government involved in the lawsuit “cannot use as a defense [the claim] that its own policy did not cause the deprivation of [the prisoner’s] constitutional rights,” and therefore the prisoner may be entitled to sue the local government over his detention.

Chesterfield’s policy now is simply to put the detainer into the prisoner’s file and stay in communication with ICE, Jones said.

“Recent federal court decisions have made clear that detaining individuals on warrantless ICE detainer requests is a violation of the detainee’s Fourth Amendment and due process rights,” said the ACLU’s Aisha Huertas Michel. The civil liberties group had sent a letter to Chesterfield county earlier this summer asking them to no longer honor the ICE detainers.

The ACLU said Virginia law already requires local jurisdictions to check someone’s immigration status when they are arrested, and when that status is checked via finger-print scan, ICE immediately flags the person for a detainer.

“It does not mean that the person being investigated is here without authority and is subject to deportation, or that there is probable cause to think they are,” clarified Huertas Michel. “It does not mean that they’ve committed a criminal violation of immigration laws or a civil violation like overstaying a student visa.”

ICE has come under fire for a number of issues related to how they treat detainees, to deportations, to how they handle protests.

Federal level immigration has seen a boost in the last decade, with their budget doubled from 2006 to $2.8 billion a year in 2013.

The use of private prison companies, and putting the detainees to work for dollars a day, has put a spotlight on the broader issue of immigration in the US.

Brad Kutner

Brad Kutner

Brad Kutner is the former editor of GayRVA and RVAMag from 2013 - 2017. He’s now the Richmond Bureau Chief for Radio IQ, a state-wide NPR outlet based in Roanoke. You can reach him at BradKutnerNPR@gmail.com




more in politics

How Are VCU Students Voting? We Asked a Few.

Early voting is already underway in Virginia ahead of the Nov. 3 midterm elections, with congressional seats and three proposed amendments to the Virginia Constitution on the ballot. Congressional races depend on where you live, but every voter in the state will see...

Richmond is Dropping Flock, But the Technology Could Remain

On October 10, Avula announced that Richmond would not renew its contract with Flock Safety, following a similar decision by Henrico County, whose contract expires in November. Richmond's agreement runs through June 30, 2027. Mayor Avula raised the possibility of a...

Old Grace Street is Richmond History. Let’s Recognize It.

Editor's note: We were sent this petition after publishing: VCU Demolition Blitz: More Richmond Erased HERE. As reported by The Richmonder last week, “The Cultural Heritage Stewardship Plan, which sailed through City Council with a unanimous vote Sept. 28, is intended...

Studio Two Three Is Beefing With Bots. Among Other Things

Studio Two Three has been around long enough to forget how likely it was to fail. Sixteen years ago, a small group of friends wanted to keep making art in Richmond. They pooled money from working in local restaurants to pay rent, borrowed equipment and built an...

Richmonders Don’t Know How Many ICE Flights Are Happening

Protestors gathered on Saturday morning outside the Richmond International Airport to oppose and call attention to the airport's role in ICE detainee transfers and deportation flights. Immigration enforcement flights out of Richmond have increased sharply...