FILM REVIEW: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

by | Jun 30, 2010

It is time for round three as The Twilight Saga: Eclipse attempts to make up for the two abysmal entries that preceded it in this series. Amazingly, this third movie does represent a bit of improvement over the first two films. Perhaps it was because of low expectations, or maybe it was because the film finally introduced some real conflict and resolutions. Regardless of the reason, this movie was not as difficult to sit through as the previous ones. That being said, many of the same old problems still remain. Being better than the first two movies does not automatically make this a good movie.

It is time for round three as The Twilight Saga: Eclipse attempts to make up for the two abysmal entries that preceded it in this series. Amazingly, this third movie does represent a bit of improvement over the first two films. Perhaps it was because of low expectations, or maybe it was because the film finally introduced some real conflict and resolutions. Regardless of the reason, this movie was not as difficult to sit through as the previous ones. That being said, many of the same old problems still remain. Being better than the first two movies does not automatically make this a good movie.

This entry picks up where the last one left off. Bella is still torn between the two young men competing for her affections. On one side, she has Edward, the vampire, and on the other is the werewolf, Jacob. Bella wants Edward to make her a vampire like him so they can be together forever, but she cannot ignore Jacob’s big muscles and his inability to wear a shirt. This is old news, though. It has been ongoing for two movies before this. The new developments for this film involve Victoria, one of the evil vampires from the first film, building an army of new vampires to kill Bella. Do not count on this movie to help you if you, like me, cannot remember why the bad vampires were after Bella in the first place. It does not really matter. What does matter is that an incoming army of vampires gives Edward and Jacob reason to put aside their rivalry and join forces.

The tension and action are very welcome in this otherwise sleepy series, but those scenes are few and far between. The majority of the movie focuses solely on the love triangle. Fans of the previous films can rejoice, for the same cringe-inducing, simplistic dialogue returns. Does Jacob really think he can win Bella’s heart just by telling her he loves her over and over again? Is Bella really so naive that she believes feeling awkward and out of place as a teenager is reason to end her human life and become a vampire? There is ample opportunity to ponder these questions as Bella, Edward, and Jacob have these same conversations about a dozen times each.

Apparently, the final book in the series is being split into two movies. Everything wraps up so neatly by the end of this film, though, that it is difficult to imagine that there is enough material to actually fill two films. Having not read the books, I am left to assume that the last one focuses on the Volturi, the secret hooded vampire council introduced in the second film. They do show up for two scenes in the third movie. They appear just long enough to take off their hoods, make a few vaguely threatening remarks to our heroes and leave. If that is what we can expect from Twilight 4 and 5, Eclipse may just turn out to be the best movie in the series.

The minor improvements found in The Twilight Saga: Eclipse have most likely come too late. Of course fans of the books and previous movies will love it, but anyone else has probably already given up on the series. It is just as well. The film is not good enough to convert any new fans. “Better than the first two” would not make for an effective tagline, but in the end it is all this movie can truly promise.

R. Anthony Harris

R. Anthony Harris

In 2005, I created RVA Magazine, and I'm still at the helm as its publisher. From day one, it’s been about pushing the “RVA” identity, celebrating the raw creativity and grit of this city. Along the way, we’ve hosted events, published stacks of issues, and, most importantly, connected with a hell of a lot of remarkable people who make this place what it is. Catch me at @majormajor____




more in community

New Menu | Richmond Grew Up. So Did Harry’s

Editor's Note: RVA Magazine is partnering with Harry's at The Hof on coverage related to their 10th anniversary celebration and new menu. We stopped by to see what was new, eat some good food, enjoy a few cocktails and report back. Richmond, we blew up our own spot....

The Fight Over Who Gets to Sell Weed

A recent report by Radio IQ suggests Virginia lawmakers are once again inching toward a legal recreational marijuana market, this time through the state budget process. Following Governor Abigail Spanberger's veto, Senate Democrats have threatened to fold retail...

Three Tall Ships, One River, 250 Years of American History

Editor's Note: RVA Magazine is partnering with the Virginia Museum of History & Culture on coverage related to America's 250th anniversary, including Richmond SailFest and the upcoming IllumiNation. Also, filmmaker Justin Black of Headwaters Down is sailing aboard...

Richmond’s Funniest Weekend Returns With 2nd Best Comedy Fest

It’s time for the 9th Annual 2nd Best Comedy Fest running June 11–13, 2026. The Coalition Theater hosts this annual event, and is the brick-and-mortar heart of Richmond's alternative comedy ecosystem. Calling it the 2nd Best Fest is a beautifully defensive undersell...

Local, Latino and A New Richmond Cosmos

Tucked into the alley behind 2512 West Main Street, a fever dream of the cosmos has taken shape across a brick wall. The mural is the collaborative work of four Latino artists working in and around Richmond: Visibly Hidden, Monolith, Mars, and Sol. A distant Earth...

The Mayor of Sunny Mart

There are certain people who become part of a neighborhood so slowly that nobody notices it happening until one day they realize the place would feel strange without them.   If you’ve spent enough time around The Fan late at night, then you probably know Sunny Mart....

Sojourner Truth and Why Her Story Still Matters

Editor's Note: This is a companion piece to our preview of Songs of Truth, the new musical inspired by the life of Sojourner Truth. This essay from Christian Detres takes a closer look at the woman behind the legend and the enduring relevance of her story. Sojourner...

Topics: