New Evidence Leads to Upgraded First Degree Murder Charge for James Fields, Accused of Charlottesville Car Attack

by | Dec 15, 2017 | COMMUNITY

The disturbing photo of bodies flying as a Dodge Challenger hurtles into them, shot from behind, has become one of the defining images of the Charlottesville rally on August 12th. The driver of that car, James Fields, faced second-degree murder charges for the death of Heather Heyer, along with felony charges for assault, wounding, and hit-and-run.

But after Thursday’s short hearing, where new video captured by restaurant security cameras was first played, Fields faces an upgraded charge of first-degree murder. The video shows Fields drive toward the crowd, stop, and reverse, repositioning before speeding into the crowd with greater momentum. Other evidence included footage and audio from the helicopter of Virginia State Police Trooper-Pilot Berke Bates and Lt. Jay Cullen, who both died when their helicopter crashed later in the day.

District Judge Robert Downer ruled that probable cause had been demonstrated for a premeditated attack, leaving Fields facing the possibility of life in prison if found guilty.

RVA Magazine has covered Charlottesville since August 12th. Every story we’ve published on this has received at least one comment asserting that Fields was defending himself and was under assault. It’s a popular conspiracy theory on YouTube and in dark corners of the web, and this new development directly contradicts it.

A common comment we receive

Prosecutors directly address the notion of self-defense in their questions for Charlottesville Detective Steven Young, who acknowledged that there was no indication that anyone had attacked Fields or his car before the crash.

The self-defense claim wasn’t addressed by his court-appointed attorney, Denise Lunsford. Instead, she asked Young a series of questions about his demeanor and connections, portraying Fields as remorseful and without ties to the white nationalist groups he had marched with.

Although Young said Fields had no known ties to the hate group, he was described by a former teacher, Derek Weimer, as being fascinated by Adolf Hitler and the Nazis. Weimer also said he’d been known to the school administration for “deeply held, radical” views on race. Young said Fields apologized when police stopped him, and cried when he learned someone had died.

The number of victims was also updated at the trial. Authorities now report 36 people injured in the attack, many of them wheelchair-bound from their injuries. A trial date for Fields will be set on Monday at a grand jury hearing.

David Streever

David Streever

David Streever was editor of the RVA Mag print quarterly from 2017 until 2018. He's written two cycling books for Falcon and covered the Tour de France and the 2015 UCI Championship in Richmond. He writes about politics, culture, cycling, and pretty much anything else.




more in community

Before Anyone Was Watching

I went to Virginia MOCA expecting to hear Andy Howell talk about skateboarding. Instead, I left thinking about community and how people find each other. Howell's installation opens Seamless, the museum's new exhibition exploring the overlap between art and design. At...

Duron Chavis is Building More Than a Farm

How two decades of community organizing grew into a vision for land ownership, education, and self-determination. The first time I met Duron Chavis, he wasn't talking about farmland. He was talking about culture. It was the early 2000s, and Happily Natural Day was...

RVA 5×5 | Leapfrogging Back to 1776, 50 Years at a Time: 1926

Editor's Note: We're sharing this essay from community content partner Jon Baliles of RVA 5x5. If you enjoy his work and want more in-depth coverage of Richmond politics and history, consider subscribing to RVA 5x5 on Substack. The views expressed are those of the...

The Light That Never Went Out 

There is a spotlight still mounted in the rafters of 528 N. 2nd Street. It has been there since 1914. It has outlasted segregation, fire, the highway that cut Jackson Ward in two, and decades of silence. On the nights when the Hippodrome Theater fills up, that light...

Virginia’s New Marijuana Law: Everything You Need to Know

After years of legislative battles, vetoes, compromise negotiations, and numerous articles, Virginia finally has a roadmap for legal recreational marijuana sales. The state budget signed into law earlier this week establishes a regulated cannabis marketplace beginning...

The Strange Afterlife of Virginia’s President Heads

Editor's Note: Reminder, the sculptures are located on private property and are not open for general visitation. Access is available only through scheduled guided tours, with Labor Day weekend currently expected to be the final tour on the calendar. Tour information...

Fourth of July 2026 in Richmond: Fireworks, Festivals, and More

The best Fourth of July celebration in Richmond probably isn't the one with the biggest fireworks. It's the one where someone forgot the hot dog buns, the cooler is running low on ice, kids are chasing each other through sprinklers, and somebody insists they know a...